Four North American Car, Truck and Utility Vehicle of the Year jurors talk about the semifinalists for the awards in a lively discussion. . .
By Gary S. Vasilash

The North American Car, Truck and Utility Vehicle of the Year (NACTOY) Award has been around since 1994. Back then, of course, utility vehicles, by and large, weren’t what they are now, vehicles, to borrow a phrase from Alfred Sloan, for every purse and purpose. So there was no category for CUVs/SUVs at the start.
But in 2017 the decision was made to add the Utility category.
That year there were three finalists:
- Chrysler Pacifica
- Jaguar F-Pace
- Mazda CX-90
Oddly, the Pacifica won. (Not that it didn’t deserve an award and it is not like minivans aren’t the most package-efficient architectures, but if were to run the elementary school test, wherein you’d show a picture of a Pacifica and a Wrangler to a 10-year-old and say, “Which is the sport utility vehicle,” odds are the Pacifica wouldn’t get the nod.)
Nowadays, the Utility category is the most-contested, by far.
The Jurors
You might be wondering just who picks the winners.
Obviously, the MotorTrend Car of the Year is selected by that publication. And there is no mistake the Car and Driver 10 Best are selected by the journalists for Car and Driver.
In the case of NACTOY, there are 50 journalists from the U.S. and Canada, a mix of people working in all types of media, from ink-on-paper to YouTube to radio.
Clearly there is an array of opinions generated by this group.
Three of the current NACTOY jurors are Henry Payne, car critic for the Detroit News (yes, he reviews trucks and utilities, too), Mark Phelan, who reviews vehicles for the Detroit Free Press, and auto writer Greg Migliore.
Oh, and I am a juror, too.
I brought the three of them together to talk about the “NACTOY Best of 2025,” a.k.a., the semifinalists, on “Autoline After Hours.”
That group of vehicles will be winnowed down to three finalists in each category. The finalists will be announced in LA on November 21, and the winners at the Detroit Auto Show on January 10, 2025.
The Vehicles
The vehicles in question at the moment are:
Cars
- BMW 3 Series
- BMW M5
- Cadillac Celestiq
- Dodge Charger EV
- Fiat 500e
- Honda Civic Hybrid
- Kia K4
- Mercedes-AMG E Class
- Porsche Panamera
- Toyota Camry
Trucks
- Ford Ranger
- GMC Sierra EV
- Ram 1500
- Rivian R1T
- Toyota Tacoma
Utilities
- Chevrolet Equinox EV
- Honda Prologue*
- Volvo EX90
- Hyundai Ioniq 5 N
- Hyundai Santa Fe
- Jeep Wagoneer S
- Lincoln Nautilus
- Porsche Macan EV
- Toyota Land Cruiser
- VW ID. Buzz
So if you’re thinking about getting a new vehicle, you might want to watch the show.
If you’re interested in a lively discussion of the offerings made by the auto industry, you certainly want to watch it.
And you can see it here.
By the way: Henry Payne goes out on the proverbial limb and names the vehicles that he thinks will win the awards. While you could simply slide that fast-forward dot on YouTube and bring it toward the end of the show to see Henry’s predictions, you’ll want to watch the whole thing to see his reasoning to get to those conclusions.

