Try to Buy a “Car”

By Gary S. Vasilash

Let’s say that you are interested in buying a car.

A car as a sedan. Not a crossover. A bread-and-butter car. (Yes, maybe you want to add some spicy tomato jam to it—spoiler, alloy wheels, etc.)

You go to the local Ford dealer.

And discover that the only car is a Mustang, which doesn’t qualify (i.e., two doors).

There happens to be a Lincoln store across the parking lot.

There are no cars, only crossovers of stair-step sizes.

You visit a Chrysler dealership and learn that Stellantis has stopped production of its long-in-the-market 300 at the end of last year, but they’ve got a Pacifica minivan, if you’re interested.

Buick perhaps? Again, no. Only crossovers.

Over at Cadillac things are better: of its seven models, two are sedans, the CT4 and the CT5. Given that the Q1 2024 sales for those are down 36.1% and 34.2%, respectively, how long they’ll be around may be in some question.

Chevy? An impressive array of crossovers and trucks. And one car, the Malibu.

The point is, buying a car is not as easy as it once was.*

Which leads to a thought about electric vehicles.

What if you went into one of these dealerships and discovered that they didn’t have anything on the showroom floor that didn’t have a plug?

What if that was pretty much the case up and down the street of the auto mall?

Clearly there would be an increase in the number of EVs sold out of those dealerships.

Maybe the numbers would be that good.

But they would be better.

Just as they’ve increased the number of models that aren’t cars and so have made buying a car tough, it could be that to help recoup some of the billions being spent on EVs they make buying an ICE tough.

Something’s got to move more of that lithium-powered metal.

(Of the 593,997 vehicles GM sold to customers in Q1, 16,169 were EVs. Not much of a business case there. And it sold twice as many Malibus ((32,749).))

*Interestingly, the Asian and European brands, in general, all have cars in their lineups.

Mercedes USA Q1 & EVs

“Mercedes-Benz EVs accounted for 13% of our total group sales volume in Q1,” Dimitris Psillakis, president and CEO of Mercedes-Benz USA, said, reporting how the marque is doing so far in 2024.

Which, on a percentage basis, is quite good.

Ford, which describes itself as “America’s No. 2 electric vehicle brand,” had Q1 EV sales of 3.9%.

Mercedes has three EVs in its U.S. showrooms:

  • EQB, of which it sold 671
  • EQE, 5,113
  • EQS, 2,552

That is a total of 8,336 of the 66,570 passenger vehicles it sold in Q1.

(To be fair to Ford, it sold 508,083 vehicles in Q1, of which 20,233 were EVs.)

But here’s something interesting about the Mercedes sales: It sold 15,096 GLE SUVs.

That’s about 23% of total sales.

EVs Mainly Elsewhere

By Gary S. Vasilash

According to stats from EV Volumes, in February the top-selling vehicles with a plug (PHEVs and EVs) were:

  1. Tesla Model Y
  2. Tesla Model 3
  3. BYD Qin Plus
  4. BYD Song
  5. AITO M7
  6. BYD Seagull/Dolphin Mini
  7. Wuling HongGuang Mini EV
  8. BYD Yuan Plus/Atto3
  9. BYD Dolphin
  10. VW ID.4
  11. Li Xiang L7
  12. Wuling Bingo
  13. BYD Han
  14. MG 4/Mulan
  15. BYD Destroyer 05 PHEV
  16. Jeep Wrangler PHEV
  17. VW ID.3
  18. Audi Q4 e-tron
  19. Li Xiang L9
  20. Chery Fengyun A8 PHEV

Here’s the thing: outside of the Teslas, VW ID.4, Wrangler, and Audi Q4 e-tron, how many of those vehicles do you have even the vaguest concept of?

There’s nothing from Toyota, Mercedes, Ford, GM BMW, Honda, or Hyundai.

This should be a reminder that when you look at EV (and PHEV) sales numbers, the world is a bigger place.

Chinese Cars in Europe

By Gary S. Vasilash

Although some people are on pins and needles and potential massive tariffs regarding Chinese vehicles coming to America, in Europe, where there is active concern on behalf of some of the OEMs on that subject, things are really not all that whelming, over- or otherwise. At least not yet.

According to Schmidt Automotive Research, during January and February, the shares of the Western European market are:

  • 13.3% Japanese OEMs
  • 7.8% Korean OEMs
  • 2.9% Chinese OEMs

However. . .

When looked at from the point of battery electric vehicles, the “Chinese model volumes combined share was 3x as large.”

So clearly Chinese OEMs are gaining some traction in the Western European market when it comes to that tech.

One interesting aspect of the penetration of Chinese vehicles of all powertrain types there is which country is most interested in acquiring them:

Italy.

Of the ~52,000 Chinese vehicles sold during the first two months, Italy took some 12,000 of them.

Which probably doesn’t make the folks at Fiat feel good.

EV Ennui

By Gary S. Vasilash

U.S. dealers are not particularly keen on electric vehicles (EVs).

So indicates the Cox Automotive Dealer Sentiment Index (CADSI) released this year.

When asked how EV sales were doing in Q1, the index score was 42. That’s off from 50 in Q1 in 2023.

And while 42 may not be particularly meaningful, know that it is the lowest score since the question was included in CADSI in Q2 2021.

The outlook among dealers regarding EV sales going forward isn’t good, either.

In Q1 2023 the index score was 53. Back then, a majority of dealers saw EV sales growing.

In Q1 2024 that index score is down to 36.

That’s the lowest score for EV outlook since that question was asked.

Seems things are no longer anticipated to be growing for EVs.

It seems as though this is not simply a U.S. phenomenon, either.

While Cox was looking at new vehicle sales, over in the U.K. and outfit that specializes in used vehicles—going from consumers to dealers rather than the more conventional vice-versa—found that sales are not particularly robust.

Compared with last year, HonkHonk found 38.5% of dealers are “much less interested” in EVs and 12.3% are “a bit less interested.”

Or 50.8% of dealers are not all that keen on putting EVs in stock.

Sebastien Duval, CEO of HonkHonk, said, “Right now, dealers can’t get enough small or medium petrol cars, medium diesels and even hybrids, since the market began recovering in 2024. But less than one in ten of them want to snap up a battery EV car more than they did than a year ago.”

That’s right: Diesels are more appealing than EVs in the U.K. used market.

Diesels.

The EV Bump That Won’t Be

By Gary S. Vasilash

“While technologically advanced, the extent that BEVs can contribute to GDP growth is limited by the maturity of the motor vehicle industry, with passenger car sales having peaked in 2017. This is a restraining factor as BEVs do not represent an innovation that creates new demand, like the introduction of personal computers or cell phones. Instead, they’re a new version of a familiar product whose sales may not grow much beyond current levels.”—Thomas Klitgaard, Federal Reserve Bank of New York

In other words, electric vehicles are not a disruptive tech that is going to bring in new buyers who otherwise wouldn’t buy an SUV, car or truck.

So even if we get to 100% EV buyers (not likely anytime soon), this is simply replacement, not buyers who would otherwise not buy a means of transportation.

Which is not what vehicle manufacturers want to think about.

Are There Enough Exclamation Points for EV Sales?

By Gary S. Vasilash

This won’t garner any headlines:

78.81% of vehicle purchases in the U.S. in 2023 were for vehicles with gasoline engines, according to Experian’s “State of the Automotive Finance Market, Q4 2023.”

The number that will is:

8.55% of the vehicles purchased were electric vehicles.

But of that “purchase,” 30.7% of the EVs were leased, which is essentially renting with the option to buy, not outright obtaining (i.e., according to the Oxford English Dictionary, the verb purchase means “To acquire in exchange for payment in money or any equivalent; to buy.” And the way the Inflation Reduction Act is constructed, for many OEMs leases are the only way that consumers can get a $7,500 purchase incentive).

A number that also won’t get large type:

9.83% were hybrids.

That number alone is about 13% greater than the EV number.

But arguably the 2.02% of vehicles purchased in 2023 that were plug-in hybrids could be added to the hybrid number, which would go to 11.85%.

Odds are that hybrid number is going to continue to grow, as will the EV number, but even though it will continue to be higher than the EV number for the next several years, you can bet every rise in EV sales will continue to get outsized attention—until the novelty passes.

How Will February Look Sales-Wise?

By Gary S. Vasilash

J.D. Power and GlobalData project that February sales will come in a smidge—1.4%–more than they were in February 2023, or 1,214,600 vehicles

Taking out non-retail transactions, the number is 981,300, which is the important number because that reflects individual consumers.

So using that as the basis of comparison, there is an increase of 3.8% compared to the same month last year.

One of the reasons for the rise this year is something that happens once every four years: an additional day of sales, February 29.

According to Thomas King, president of the data and analytics division at J.D. Power, the increase in sales is facilitated by:

  • Higher inventory levels (when there are cars on the lot, then there is less pressure to have to select whatever is available from a paltry number)
  • Higher manufacturer incentives (turns out that there is a need to provide a boost to get the sheet metal moving)
  • Lower dealer profit margins (seems that the profits that were rolling in when choice was minimal so prices were maximal are now trending back to normal—but it is worth noting that about 17% of vehicles are still selling above MSRP, although last year it was nearly 32%)

What this means is that people are getting bullishly back in the market.

King:

“Transaction prices in February are trending towards $44,045, down $1,919 or 4.2%—from February 2023. However, despite the significant decline in average transaction prices, higher sales volumes mean consumers are on track to spend nearly $40.8 billion on new vehicles this month—the highest on record for the month of February, and 4.1% higher than February 2023.”

Could be a case of the proverbial “making it up on volume.”

Nowadays, it is impossible not to look at how things are going in terms of EV sales.

Elizabeth Krear, vice president, electric vehicle practice at J.D. Power, said, “In 2023, EV sales and leases accounted for a larger percentage of retail auto industry growth than gas-powered vehicles.”

Presumably that has something to do with the fact that there is a stable number of gas-powered vehicles so the growth would not be as big as that of EVs, which start from a comparatively smaller number.”

She acknowledged what is now frequently heard: EV sales are slowing.

Putting some numbers to it:

“In January, battery electric vehicle sales fell 1.6 percentage points from 9.2% in December 2023. Further, upper-funnel EV shopper interest declined for a fourth consecutive month. New-vehicle shoppers who are ‘very likely’ to consider purchasing an EV for their next vehicle dropped to 25.6%, a full percentage point lower than in December.”

Krear said that a big blockage for EV buyers: charging access.

While she noted that the opening of the Tesla Supercharger network will go a long way toward addressing that issue, she added, “But this alone is not enough to move the needle. Improvement is needed in terms of the availability of affordable EVs for mainstream customers.”

Yes, it all comes down to an affordable MSRP.

Euro Auto Sales Fun Fact

In 2023 Nissan sold 343,891 vehicles in Europe, a 20.1% increase over its sales there in 2022, according to Inovev.

In 2023 Chinese brands sold 353,276 vehicles—“mainly based on BEVs”—in Europe, more than double their sales there in 2022.

The MG MG4 EV: second only to the Tesla Model Y in U.K. 2023 sales. MG is owned by Shanghai-based SAIC Motor. (Image: MG)

Nissan, which has been around in the European market for a while (and had been affiliated with Renault until last year), is already surpassed by a phalanx of Chinese OEMs. (Yes, this is one company vs. several, but looked at from the point of view of sheet metal moved, it is still worth pondering.)

Maybe if you’re Stellantis or Renault or Volkswagen this isn’t a particularly fun fact.

And maybe this will portend things happening at some point in the U.S., as well.

Western Europe, China and EVs

Although there was a seeming step-by-step, vehicle-by-vehicle increase in the under of Chinese battery electric vehicles registered in Western Europe last year, there was a bit of a stumble at the end, and Schmidt Automotive Research wonders whether there will be a cap of under 10% of the EV market in Western Europe for the Sino mobiles.

(Image: Schmidt Automotive Research)

As the chart shows, there was a noticeable decline in registrations in Q4. . .but then there are some reasons why this could be the case, including the increase in the amount of time it takes to ship vehicles from China to Europe while avoiding the Red Sea.

But the Schmidt study also points out some brands are offering discounts of up to €12,000, so you’d imagine that European consumers would be most interested in savings like that. . .especially as there may be higher import tariffs applied to Chinese vehicles coming into Europe this year.

Still, the fact that the Chinese OEMs have managed to gain that much of the European market in a comparatively short period of time says something about the appeal of their products.